Amy McFadden

209 audiobooks · 161,086 performance ratings

Romance Literature & Fiction Mystery, Thriller & Suspense Science Fiction & Fantasy Comedy & Humor

Listeners rate Amy McFadden's narration above the writing, 4.55 for performance against 4.39 for story. They're prolific, with 209 audiobooks and 161,086 performance ratings. Their standout is Blood Gamble, rated 4.75 for performance, with most of their work in Romance and Literature & Fiction.

4.55

Performance

4.39

Story

4.42

Overall

Best-performed titles

#
1	Kindred Spirits A.J. Aalto	5.00	4.84	4.85	74
2	Wrath & Bones A.J. Aalto	4.92	4.80	4.82	171
3	A Promise in the Keys Hope Holloway	4.90	4.87	4.87	389
4	Dire: Hell Andrew Seiple	4.90	4.73	4.75	268
5	A New Year in the Keys Hope Holloway	4.89	4.82	4.82	347
6	Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus Betrayal Lydia Sherrer	4.88	4.76	4.81	189
7	Island Chaptal and the Ancient Aliens' Treasure Camilla Monk	4.88	4.68	4.73	108
8	A Wedding in the Keys Hope Holloway	4.88	4.90	4.85	215
9	Elude Rachel Van Dyken	4.88	4.88	4.88	139
10	A Haven in the Keys Hope Holloway	4.87	4.85	4.84	240
11	Blightmare A.J. Aalto	4.87	4.72	4.77	167
12	Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus Odyssey Lydia Sherrer	4.86	4.73	4.80	79
13	Spotless Series Boxed Set Camilla Monk	4.86	4.60	4.64	93
14	Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus Identity Lydia Sherrer	4.86	4.78	4.82	223
15	A Reunion in the Keys Hope Holloway	4.85	4.87	4.87	567
16	Love, Lies, and Hocus Pocus Kindred Lydia Sherrer	4.85	4.72	4.74	193
17	Dire: Wars Andrew Seiple	4.85	4.67	4.72	193
18	A Return to the Keys Hope Holloway	4.85	4.84	4.80	236
19	Plain Choice Sarah Price	4.84	4.74	4.75	184
20	Dire: Time Andrew Seiple	4.84	4.50	4.57	354
21	Dire: Sins Andrew Seiple	4.84	4.74	4.77	191
22	The Marnie Baranuik Files A.J. Aalto	4.83	4.64	4.56	95
23	House of Gods K.A. Linde	4.83	4.73	4.74	123
24	Long Live the Soulless Kel Carpenter, Lucinda Dark	4.82	4.70	4.71	362
25	Shadow Hunt Melissa F. Olson	4.82	4.76	4.76	936

1–25 of 209

Ratings sourced from Audible, updated June 23, 2026. Performance is the average of each title's narration rating, weighted by number of ratings.